(Image via usatoday.com)

2007 > Edu, TFC
2006 > Wynne, NY
2005 > Besagno, RSL
2004 > Adu, DC
2003 > Eskandarian, DC
2002 > Gbandi, DAL
2001 > Carrieri, SJ
2000 > Shak, MET
1999 > Moore, DC
1998 > Cullen , MIA
1997 > Jakins, COL
1996 > McBride, CLB