Lee Mason and Mike Jones axed while ‘Phantom Goal’ official Stuart Attwell gets a game at Manchester City

Filed under: Refs

3.jpg

the Daily Mail is reporting that two Premier League referees have been appointed as fourth officials after their performances last Saturday piled more pressure on managers Rafael Benitez and Phil Brown - with Stuart Attwell restored to the top flight.

Liverpool’s Benitez and Hull’s Brown were both the victims of contentious judgements during defeats for their sides last weekend but the two under-fire bosses weren’t the only ones to suffer the consequences as referees Lee Mason and Mike Jones have been removed from the middle at all levels.

Liverpool, who had two players sent off by Mason at Fulham, are appealing against the dismissal of Philipp Degen having also considered contesting Jamie Carragher’s red card in  the 3-1 defeat.

1.jpg

Liverpool’s Jamie Carragher as Lee Mason is about to send him off

Hull, beaten 2-0 at  Burnley, have no recourse to appeal over Geovanni’s sending-off for two yellow cards. The Brazilian had earlier had a goal controversially disallowed  while Burnley’s penalty opener was also considered a faulty call by Jones,  the man at the centre of Sunderland’s ‘beach ball  goal’ against Liverpool a  fortnight earlier.

Mason and Jones have both been relegated to fourth official duties in the top flight this weekend. At one time errant referees were temporarily dropped to a lower level but Football League complaints against that policy then led to a system of ‘benching’ them.

Professional Game Match Officials routinely punish officials for  high-profile errors and  action was swift yesterday following an examination of  a weekend programme that  produced nine red cards in the Premiership.

Liverpool’s hope to have Degen cleared at today’s appeal hearing.

The Swiss midfielder was shown a straight red card for a foul on Clint Dempsey that most experts viewed as a cautionable offence at worst.

There were also  protests over Carragher’s dismissal for checking a run by Bobby Zamora that  denied a goalscoring opportunity.

While the foul looked  less than blatant  on replays, Liverpool have decided it would be difficult to  defend especially as  there was no doubt about Zamora being through on goal.

Hull, whose struggle  for Premiership survival has put Brown under threat, had reason to be even more aggrieved over the circumstances of their defeat at Turf Moor.

2.jpg

Hull City’s Kamel Ghilas appeals to Mike Jones after he awarded a penalty against Burnley

Brown’s side fell behind to a soft penalty and were denied an equaliser  for an alleged  minor infringement in the wall when Geovanni arrowed in a  free-kick. The Brazilian was then dismissed following a routine foul.

The fact that both Brown  and Benitez were conspicuously restrained in their comments about the officials afterwards has been noted with appreciation by refereeing chiefs. They have honoured a pledge to managers to make officials accountable.

A further appeal to the FA  today concerns a yellow card picked up by  Aston Villa’s Stephen Warnock in  their 1-1 draw at Everton. Warnock is  claiming mistaken identity  on the part of referee Lee Probert.

This weekend’s biggest game  goes to Martin Atkinson, who takes charge of Sunday’s Stamford Bridge clash between Chelsea and Manchester United.

Meanwhile, Attwell, famous for awarding Reading a ‘Phantom Goal’ at Watford despite the ball going four yards wide at Vicarage Road 14 months ago, is moving back up the pecking order.

Attwell, 26, has been appointed to Manchester City v Burnley on Saturday.

He became the youngest-ever Premier League ref in August last year but has proved a controversial figure, attracting criticism from the likes of Benitez, Steve Bruce and Wolves after his handling of the 1-1 draw at Everton last month in which he sent off Stefan Maierhoffer and allowed an Everton goal to stand despite an apparent foul on an opponent in the build-up.

source and images

Share/Save/Bookmark
Posted on Nov 3rd, 2009 by  isps 

Leave your comment